Holmes vs Momentic

Momentic explores your app and writes tests for your repo.Holmes tests from goals, with no test files to keep.

Both use AI agents that explore your app, repair tests when the UI changes and check every pull request, and both price on usage, not seats. Momentic is built for developers who own the suite as YAML code. Holmes works from plain-language goals the whole team can read, and adds accessibility and API checks, context from designs and analytics, and a summary of every release.

€250 in free credits · No credit card

At a glance

Choose Momentic if

  • Your developers want tests as YAML code, reviewed in their own pull requests.[3][4]
  • You want to run tests on your own machines or inside your network.[5][6]
  • You want test cases synced to TestRail, Qase or Testiny.[22]

Choose Holmes if

  • Product, QA and engineering should all read and write tests as plain-language goals.
  • You want accessibility (WCAG) and API checks in the same run as your journeys.
  • You want testing to start from the Figma design and your PostHog analytics as well as tickets and specs.
  • You want a plain-language summary of what changed in every release, tested.

What Holmes adds to Momentic

  1. Goals instead of test files

    Momentic is built for developers who write and maintain YAML specs in the repo. Holmes works from plain-language goals, so product and QA can write and review tests too, with no test code to maintain.

  2. Accessibility and API checks in the same run

    Holmes runs WCAG audits in a real browser, keyboard navigation included, and checks every request behind a journey. Momentic can call APIs from a test step, but dedicated API checks and WCAG audits aren't described on its pages.

  3. Context from designs and analytics

    Both read tickets and specs from Jira, Linear, Notion and Confluence. Holmes also reads the design in Figma and your top pages in PostHog before it decides what to test.

  4. A summary of every release

    When something ships, Holmes writes what changed in plain language, then tests the journeys the change touched, so the whole team knows what went out.

Holmes and Momentic, side by side

Based on each product's public pages on 17 November 2026. A red cross means Momentic's pages don't describe it, not that it can't be done.

Holmes compared with Momentic
CapabilityHolmesMomentic
Testing
Who it's built forYes: Engineering, QA and product in the same loop, with unlimited usersNote: Developers and DevX engineers who write and maintain the suite[7]
How tests are writtenYes: Plain-language goals. No test code to writeYes: Plain-English prompts, a coding-agent skill or a web editor[3]
Where tests liveYes: In Holmes, as plain-language goals. Existing test cases import from a file, Jira, Linear, Notion or ConfluenceYes: YAML specs in your repo; Mo opens a pull request with each new test[3][4]
Finds bugs nobody scriptedYes: Agents explore and test paths nobody wrote downYes: Its Mo agent explores with parallel agents and reports each bug with reproduction steps[8]
Keeps tests working when the UI changesYes: Flows repair themselves when a label or layout changesYes: Locators re-resolve; lasting fixes arrive as an auto-heal pull request[9][10]
Web browsersYes: Chromium, Firefox and WebKit, the engine behind SafariYes: Chromium, Google Chrome and Chrome for Testing[11]
Native Android appsYes: Native Android apps on an Android emulatorYes: Native Android, React Native, Expo and Flutter on local or hosted emulators[12]
Native iOS appsYes: Native iOS apps on iPhone and iPad simulatorsYes: On local or hosted simulators; out of beta[1][2]
Real devicesNot covered: Not covered. Android emulators and iOS simulatorsNote: Simulators and emulators; its Mo page says human testers still cover physical hardware[1][13]
APIsYes: Every request behind a journey, checked in contextPartly: HTTP and GraphQL request steps inside tests; no standalone API suite[32]
AccessibilityYes: WCAG audits in a real browser, with keyboard navigationNot described: Not on its pages. WCAG audits
Workflow
Pull requests and previewsYes: Check and comment on GitHub and Bitbucket pull requests. GitLab supportedYes: A required check on pull requests; finds Vercel, Cloudflare Pages or Netlify previews[14][15]
Schedules and CIYes: On every deploy, on a schedule, or by webhookYes: On a schedule, or in GitHub Actions, CircleCI, Buildkite, Jenkins or another CI[14][16]
Where tests runYes: Holmes' cloud, in isolated containers destroyed after each sessionYes: Your own machines, your CI or Momentic-hosted infrastructure[5]
Context it reads before testingYes: Reads the code change, ticket, spec (Notion, Confluence), design (Figma) and analytics (PostHog)Partly: Tickets and specs from Linear, Jira, Confluence and Notion. Figma or analytics aren't on its pages[17]
Coding agents (MCP)Yes: Start runs and read findings from Claude and Cursor via MCPYes: CLIs and MCP servers for Claude Code, Cursor and Devin[18]
Evidence with each bugYes: Recording, screenshots, console and network logs, steps to reproduceYes: Repro steps, a screenshot or recording, video and trace, browser logs and network requests[19][20][21]
Flaky resultsYes: Multi-stage validation. Borderline issues re-tested by an independent evaluatorYes: Flaky tests go to quarantine instead of blocking the pipeline[9]
Where findings goYes: Findings on the pull request, the ticket, Slack, Microsoft Teams and emailYes: Bugs to Jira or Linear; Slack alerts; test cases sync to TestRail, Qase or Testiny[22][33]
Release summariesYes: Plain-language summary of what changed in each releaseNot described: Not on its pages. A summary of what changed in each release
Pricing and security
What you pay forYes: Priced on how much Holmes tests, never on seatsNote: Usage: test steps, AI steps and browser or simulator minutes[23][24]
UsersYes: Unlimited users on every planNote: Not priced on seats; invite the whole team[23]
Entry priceYes: Free plan. Paid plans from €199 ($219) a monthNote: Free with $50 of usage a month; Scale $500 a month[25][26]
AI and your dataYes: Zero-data-retention AI processing. Source code is never storedNote: Zero-data-retention with its AI providers. Self-serve data can improve Momentic's own agents; Enterprise can opt out[27][28][29]
Inside your networkNot covered: Not covered. Cloud onlyPartly: Control plane in Momentic's cloud; CLI execution can run inside your network[6]
Help getting startedYes: Self-serve. Setup in under ten minutesNote: Self-serve; on Enterprise its team helps you evaluate, migrate and roll out[30]
Company baseYes: EU company (Ghent, Belgium), GDPR compliantNote: San Francisco, California; Y Combinator W24[31]

Holmes sells QA software, so we compete with Momentic. We've tried to be fair: every statement about Momentic comes from its own public pages, linked below with the date we checked them. Products change. If something here is out of date, email support@useholmes.com and we'll fix it.

Sources

  1. Momentic, Enterprise: Local or hosted iOS simulators and Android emulators. Hosted iOS can mock a camera feed. Checked 17 November 2026.
  2. Momentic, Home: iOS and Android testing are out of beta. Checked 17 November 2026.
  3. Momentic, About: Authoring: plain-English prompts, the momentic-spec skill, or the web editor. Tests are YAML specs checked into your repo. Checked 17 November 2026.
  4. Momentic, Home: Mo turns a flow you approve into a Momentic YAML test and opens a pull request in your repo. Checked 17 November 2026.
  5. Momentic, Home: Run tests on your own machines, in CI, or on Momentic-hosted infrastructure. Checked 17 November 2026.
  6. Momentic, Enterprise: Not today. The control plane runs in Momentic's cloud. CLI execution can run inside your network Checked 17 November 2026.
  7. Momentic, About: developers and DevX engineers who write and maintain the suite, not a separate QA org. Checked 17 November 2026.
  8. Momentic docs, Mo: It explores the app with parallel agents and returns a report of what it checked, what it couldn’t verify, and each bug with reproduction steps. Checked 17 November 2026.
  9. Momentic, About: Locators re-resolve when the UI moves, failure recovery patches the step, and permanent healing writes the fix back to the spec. Flaky tests go to quarantine instead of blocking the pipeline. Checked 17 November 2026.
  10. Momentic docs, Auto-maintenance: An auto-heal pull request records the root cause, fix, and validation Checked 17 November 2026.
  11. Momentic, Web app testing: Web tests run on Chromium, Google Chrome, and Chrome for Testing; iOS on hosted simulators, Android on hosted emulators. Checked 17 November 2026.
  12. Momentic, Enterprise: Native Android, React Native, Expo, and Flutter apps on local or remote emulators. Checked 17 November 2026.
  13. Momentic, Mo: human testers still cover physical hardware and local product requirements Checked 17 November 2026.
  14. Momentic, Home: Run saved tests on a schedule, on every PR, or in CI, and use the result as a required check. Checked 17 November 2026.
  15. Momentic docs, GitHub: Otherwise Mo checks the PR’s head commit once for Vercel, Cloudflare Pages, or Netlify preview links. Checked 17 November 2026.
  16. Momentic, Infrastructure: Run repository tests in GitHub Actions, CircleCI, Buildkite, Jenkins, or your existing CI provider. Checked 17 November 2026.
  17. Momentic docs, Mo: Integrations such as Linear, Jira, Confluence, and Notion, plus custom MCP servers your workspace adds, give it tickets and specs. Checked 17 November 2026.
  18. Momentic, About: The momentic and momentic-mobile CLIs and MCP servers give Claude Code, Cursor, Devin, and other agents the ability to write and run real UI tests. Checked 17 November 2026.
  19. Momentic, Home: Mo files each bug with repro steps, expected and actual behavior, and a screenshot or recording. Checked 17 November 2026.
  20. Momentic docs, GitHub: The comment links each run back to the dashboard’s video, trace, and step evidence. Checked 17 November 2026.
  21. Momentic, Infrastructure: Browser logs and network requests help you trace a UI failure to its cause. Checked 17 November 2026.
  22. Momentic, Mo: its test cases sync to TestRail, Qase, or Testiny, and an accepted bug files to Jira or Linear. Checked 17 November 2026.
  23. Momentic, Pricing: No. Pricing is based on usage, not seats. Invite your whole team; you pay for what your tests use. Checked 17 November 2026.
  24. Momentic, Pricing: $0.0125 / step Checked 17 November 2026.
  25. Momentic, Pricing: $50 of free usage each month. Checked 17 November 2026.
  26. Momentic, Pricing: Scale costs $500 per month and includes $500 of usage, billed in advance. Checked 17 November 2026.
  27. Momentic, Security: Momentic has zero-data-retention agreements with its AI providers. Checked 17 November 2026.
  28. Momentic, Security: Data from self-serve accounts can be used to improve Momentic's own agents. Checked 17 November 2026.
  29. Momentic, Enterprise: Enterprise customers can opt out of using their data to improve Momentic's agents. Checked 17 November 2026.
  30. Momentic, Enterprise: Our team helps you evaluate, migrate, and roll out. Checked 17 November 2026.
  31. Momentic, About: Momentic was founded in 2023 and is headquartered in San Francisco, California. The company is a Y Combinator W24 company. Checked 17 November 2026.
  32. Momentic docs, request: Runs server-side without going through the browser. Combine with `saveAs` to feed the response into later steps. Checked 17 November 2026.
  33. Momentic docs, Slack: The Slack integration posts to your workspace when Momentic has something to report Checked 17 November 2026.

How each one works

The same job, step by step: from deciding what to test to telling you what broke.

  1. Deciding what to test

    Momentic

    Mo reads tickets and specs from Linear, Jira, Confluence and Notion, plus any custom MCP servers you add.[17]

    Holmes

    Holmes reads the code change, the ticket, the spec in Notion or Confluence, the design in Figma and your top pages in PostHog.

  2. Writing the test

    Momentic

    You write plain-English prompts or use the web editor, or Mo turns a flow you approve into a YAML test and opens a pull request.[3][4]

    Holmes

    You describe the journey in plain language, or Holmes builds it from a ticket or from exploring your product. It saves the flow; there is no test code.

  3. Running it

    Momentic

    On every pull request, on a schedule or in your CI, on your own machines or on Momentic-hosted infrastructure.[14][5]

    Holmes

    On every pull request and preview, on deploy, on a schedule, by webhook, or from Slack, Claude or Cursor, in isolated cloud containers.

  4. When the UI changes

    Momentic

    Locators re-resolve, failure recovery patches the step, and lasting fixes arrive as an auto-heal pull request.[9][10]

    Holmes

    Agents understand the page and repair the flow when a label or layout changes.

  5. Telling you what broke

    Momentic

    Each bug comes with repro steps, expected and actual behaviour and a screenshot or recording; accepted bugs file to Jira or Linear, and Slack gets an alert.[19][22]

    Holmes

    Each finding passes multi-stage validation, then arrives with a recording, screenshots, console and network logs and repro steps, on the pull request, the ticket, Slack, Teams or email.

Questions about Holmes and Momentic

What is the main difference between Holmes and Momentic?

They are close. Both use AI agents that explore your app, repair tests when the UI changes and check pull requests, and both price on usage. Momentic is built for developers: its tests are YAML specs in your repo. Holmes works from plain-language goals the whole team can read, reads designs and analytics as well as tickets and specs, adds accessibility and API checks, and writes a summary of every release.[3]

Who is each one built for?

Momentic says it is built for teams that own quality in CI: developers and DevX engineers who write and maintain the suite, not a separate QA org. Holmes is built for engineering, QA and product together: tests are plain-language goals, and every plan has unlimited users.[7]

Do both test mobile apps?

Holmes tests native Android and iOS apps on emulators and simulators. Momentic tests native iOS and Android apps, including React Native, Expo and Flutter, on local or hosted simulators and emulators. Neither runs on real devices; Momentic's Mo page says human testers still cover physical hardware.[1][12][13]

How does pricing compare?

Both are priced on usage, not seats. Momentic's Free plan includes $50 of usage a month, Scale is $500 a month with $500 of usage included, and Enterprise is custom. Holmes has a Free plan with €250 in credits to start, Starter at €199 a month for up to 3 products, and Team from €499 a month, all with unlimited users.[25][26][23]

Where do the tests live?

Momentic keeps tests as YAML specs in your repo and runs them on your own machines, in CI or on its hosted infrastructure. Holmes keeps plain-language goals in Holmes and runs them in isolated cloud containers, so there is no test code to maintain. You can import existing test cases into Holmes from a file, from Jira, Linear, Notion or Confluence, or from the top journeys in your analytics.[3][5]

How does each one deal with flaky tests and false alarms?

Momentic re-resolves locators, patches failing steps and sends flaky tests to quarantine instead of blocking the pipeline. Holmes runs every finding through multi-stage validation, and an independent evaluator re-tests borderline issues, so what reaches your team is a bug worth reading.[9]

What happens to my data?

Momentic has zero-data-retention agreements with its AI providers; data from self-serve accounts can be used to improve Momentic's own agents, and Enterprise customers can opt out. Holmes uses zero-data-retention for all AI processing, never stores your source code, and runs in isolated containers that are destroyed after each session. See the Holmes Trust Center for details.[27][28][29]

When might Momentic be the better fit?

If you want tests as code reviewed in your own pull requests, need to run tests inside your network, or want test cases synced to TestRail, Qase or Testiny, Momentic covers those on its own pages. If you want plain-language goals the whole team can work with, context from specs, designs and analytics, and accessibility and API checks in one run, try Holmes.[1][3][6][22]

Further reading

Evaluating Momentic? See what Holmes finds first.

Your bugs in your inbox, 30 minutes from now.

Free, no scripts, no SDK, and no test account needed to start.